Paging Troy McClure

I remember actor Troy McClure, voiced by the late great Phil Hartman, hosting a special episode of "The Simpsons" which featured some possible spinoffs of the show. They were quite silly, and consequently funny to look at. "Could they really be that dumb?", I thought.

Apparently, "they" could, if "The Cleveland Show" is any indication. I've touched on the before, but found a much better discussion of the issue from The New Republic's John McWhorter.

McWhorter's point is that the show is simply a retread of Family Guy with black characters in the main roles:

The Cleveland Show is reminiscent of all-black productions of musicals in the old days such as the Hello, Dolly! with Pearl Bailey. The underlying notion was that because you couldn’t cast a black performer in a non-black role in a mainstream production, it made theatrical sense to concoct an occasion for there to be a black Dolly, a black Horace Vandergelder, a black Barnaby singing “It Only Takes a Moment.” What mattered was not the particulars of the performances – the names of the performers in these all-black mock-ups, other than the superstar leads, were quickly forgotten – but the fact that black people were doing them at all.

So, instead of a new comedy with a strong cast, McWhorter argues we're getting Family Guy in blackface, and I find it hard to disagree.